Lara Croft Tomb Raider le Berceau de la Vie

Jan de Bont a eu un scénario plus varié avec des lieux exotiques et une fin plus spectaculaire pour son premier film, mais il n'a pas brillé plus en tant que réalisateur que Simon West ici. L'action de West est inaboutie, ennuyeuse et sans saveur, comme un film B. En général, la suite est légèrement meilleure que le premier volet fade, mais cela ne suffit toujours pas à atteindre une moyenne plus élevée. Le verdict final est le même : si le film vaut la peine d'être vu, c'est grâce à Angelina Jolie de plus en plus sexy jour après jour. (21/07/2003)

The film crew may have had a lot of fun travelling to various locations around the world, but the same cannot be said for the audience. After Twister, De Bonte shows nothing but creative stagnation. What can I say, the locations are attractive and Angela's role fits like a glove when everything else fails. The script is pathetic, the action is dull, the direction is inept, I didn't care what happened in the next few minutes, I didn't live with the main characters and that's too bad. The only thing that snapped me out of my lethargy was the mini-role of my favourite actor Djimon Hounsou, which is woefully inadequate for a two-hour film, admittedly. Overall, even the weak first Tomb Raider was better than this sequel. But The Cradle of Life has one thing that stands out, and that's probably the most embarrassing plot finale I've seen in years. That's why it was deservedly a commercial flop. (09/07/2004)

If Simon West tried to have a little bit of style, De Bont put a stop to that and he conceived the directing in a relaxing way instead. You'd be booed for that even in a B-movie. Boring, conservative, cumbersome, and completely unsuitable to Lara Croft's profile as a light-footed and brisk acrobat. So, it’s even a little worse than the first film, and that can already be considered a state close to disaster. Luckily, you can see the increased budget at least a little (the effects are ok, the soundtrack noticeable)... But there is no improvement in the plot itself, Lady Croft still defines her place in the world only with awkward poses, Chris Barrie is buried more than last time, and the story is no less stupid and dull. The filmmakers take you to several exotic locations that uniformly crack into a confused amalgam of action and retarded dialogues. My impression of the film is perfectly captured by the scene where the chief of the African tribe promises Lara what she will see in the cradle of life. The fact that we see a flashing stroboscope instead of the terrible secrets may not surprise the viewer. I very much hope that Lara Croft is definitely done after this film, because she has already had enough embarrassment. (11/11/2004)

One would say that when creators dare to make a sequel to a failed film, they do so with the intention of coming up with some refreshing ideas and bringing some innovation. However, compared to the second installment, the original Tomb Raider looks like a magnificent and profound film. This is a total disaster that definitively sunk the potentially attractive character of Lara and moreover probably destroyed Chris Barrie's possible late Hollywood career. Complete nonsense with unremarkable actors (including Angelina), confusing action, and dreadful effects. Never again. Perhaps only in a remake. (20/05/2006)

Compared to the first movie, this is ever so slightly better, not in terms of quality, but entertainment. It certainly isn’t such sleep-making boredom as last time. The screenplay is even worse and dumber. However, the production design and directing have considerably improved. The result is spoiled by the movie being too long, and the “dialogs" and the scenes aren’t even up to B-movie quality. Particularly Lara versus the shark is an experience for connoisseurs who like falling off their seats with laughter at the expense of the creators (or was this a clever nod to the cult scene from Zombie Flesh Eaters?). Again it is Angelina Jolie who carries this picture on her shoulders, well supported by Chris Barrie. This second jab at becoming a second Indy fails again. (13/03/2005)