Star Trek Nemesis

Avec une intrigue, une seule épisode de série télévisée suffirait aisément, mais le traitement formel fantastique nous indique que les créateurs nous veulent du bien. (27/10/2003)

The conclusion of the Generation Saga could not have been better! True, the story lacks the monumentality and fatality of the Borg episodes of the series, but Captain Pickard's duel with himself in another body is worth it. The Romulans have not been seen much in the series so far, so it's good that they're finally getting some screen time. Although I probably don't have to emphasize the fact that they are not in a particularly friendly mood and that they have truly evil plans concerning the Federation. The story does have a touch of seriality, but thanks to the conflict between the two main brains on both sides, it has the right feature film spirit. In addition, director Stuart Baird has not forgotten what we, ST+, love so much – light humor and exaggeration for the "invited", a spectacular starship duel (the battle between the Enterprise and the Scimitar is one of the best in the history of Star trek) and a great escalation of intergalactic tension... He has also added a revolutionary novelty in the form of a dropping of paratroops, carried out not on foot, as I am used to in Star Trek, but through futuristic Off-road. And the fact that it is more than just driving is definitely clear. One of the last Mohicans of the old school soundtrack, Jerry Goldsmith, contributed really great music to it all. It’s quite unfortunate that the previous episode of Insurrection failed quite deservedly, and thereby our fellow countryman didn't have a chance to enjoy a delicious Star Trek Generations film on the silver screen. I would give it 4 or 5 stars, but out of respect for what the Generations has accomplished, I’m rounding up... Unfortunately, the bonus material on the DVD clearly shows how much the Paramount studio was involved in the film, which (as director Baird conspicuously suggests) forced the creator to cut out certain important scenes. The alternative ending in the cut-out scenes is also interesting, clearly suggesting that Nemesis should not have been the certain ending of the Next Generation. Unlike the ending which was used. (14/09/2004)

The classic archetypal battle for the salvation of all is crossed with a perfect morally-responsible dilemma. Enterprise faces the most stylish enemy of the entire film series, and the entire Romulan plot is presented so darkly that I couldn't believe that it was this crew that started in the failed Generations. The Next Generation could hardly say goodbye better. (18/10/2009)

In the context of the entire ST film series, Nemesis is a slight above-average film given the partially logical development of the genre and the possibilities of trick technology. It is clearly weaker than First Contact and clearly better than Insurrection. I have a slight problem with the screenplay, but Nemesis is mainly brought down by the traditional shortcomings of the series. Except for First Contact, I couldn't shake the impression with other ST films that they were merely extended TV episodes with clearly defined and unchanging characters and a scheme... Overall rating 65%. I am still waiting for a truly great dramatic and captivating story. (07/08/2007)

Probably the first episode only with a new crew, which I really liked. Mainly because I could feel the emotions. Yes, it's stretched out, there are scenes that may seem long, but I actually quite enjoyed them. And the ending is pleasant. You don't even have to be such a fan to get into it. Nice, positive, epic, cool. (14/04/2015)