Hostiles

Sur la façon dont le film examine profondément les sentiments de tous les personnages, il a quelque peu sous-estimé l'importance de la représentation pour exposer la relation clé de la personnage de Bale avec le chef. Cela peut être dû au montage final, qui a raccourci la durée du film pour le rendre plus accessible à un large public. Je ferais de la première moitié la première partie et j'étirerais la durée à 150 minutes. Hostiles sont si captivants, émotionnels et engageants sur le plan psychologique et intellectuel qu'ils auraient pu devenir le (anti)western de la décennie, qui représente le plus précisément cette période troublée de l'histoire américaine parmi tous les autres genres. Chaque minute est un témoignage intense des pertes, des souffrances et de la tristesse. (08/08/2018)

A wonderful story by the sensitive Scott Cooper. Minimalistically served, modestly presented but profound in its message. The moments of silence, thoughtfully spoken dialogue and knowing glances were more engaging for me than the scenes of horror and violence, which also have their place. I can see why this flopped in theaters, in this day and age of superhero Marvel and DC dreck, this old-school style of narrative is out of place with 99% of today's film output. And I understand why Christian Bale wants to make films like this, and I thank him for that and wish him well in his future film career. (11/06/2018)

The premise gave me a feeling that this would be one of the best Hollywood experiences. And it really was. It has exactly everything is should and nothing more, nothing less. Christian Bale and Wes Studi greatly portray the best warriors of their respective sides and as destiny has planned, at the end of their lives they meet again just so one of them can carry the other home. And it is done on the President’s order. Brutal bloody scenes, unbelievably strong emotions, characters you pity, the darkness in their minds you can’t understand and the scenes you won’t forget. Undoubtedly a great experience and the last scene is probably the most beautiful and poetic movie ending I have seen in years. (07/10/2020)

The first cinema experience of the year. Scott Cooper serves up a gritty adventure western with the Apache! Starring a solid Christian Bale, Rosamund Pike and Ben Foster. The film has a slower pace, but a very tense atmosphere, beautiful scenery, lots of disgusting maniacal Apaches who have no problem murdering an entire family and their children (the opening scene is very intense) and a great soundtrack. There are only four action scenes, but they are authentically filmed, with excellent sound design and very tense to the point of being breathless. This dead genre has been slowly reviving and gaining momentum for the last two years and that's only a good thing. 75% (16/01/2018)

Nontraditional western with almost philosophical contemplations about death. Mainly about the death of loved ones. In his role of a mumbling captain, Bale caught the right wave again, his torn soul shining in his eyes. In her supporting role, Rosamund Pike skillfully steals the strongest scenes for herself e.g. with the sleeping children and shooting the corpse. A story wrapped inside an almost ironical pilgrimage towards death also boasts amazing visuals. There could be more of Foster, he makes just a fleeting appearance. I was just doing my job. (20/07/2018)

Fortunately, Scott Cooper understood that Black Mass was a failed test of a new course for his directing career and that the ideal thing to do was to return to what he does best. Hostiles copies the signature of Out of the Furnace, it’s slow, full of violence and raw emotions. Instead of a purely masculine take, this time he incorporates a strong feminine element as well, and he has succeeded to perfection. It dilutes the macho western, giving it a dramatic dimension and a strong emotional arc, for it is the scenes with Rosamund Pike that are often chilling, sometimes at least very compelling and understandable to the viewer. Christian Bale plays a similar role to his present-day brother, a few years older, he doesn’t say much, but does a lot. On the one hand, this is a gritty, absolutely classically conveyed story (the clash of whites and native savages) of a typical western, and at the same time they subliminally play an interesting game of hatred and reconciliation, where the characters are neither clearly good nor clearly bad and it is often just a matter of point of view and understanding. The great cinematography and the unique scenery of Wyoming and Montana add to the wistful atmosphere, supported by Max Richter's soaring violin. A Western without unnecessary experiments, solid in the basics, a successful return to the roots. (15/04/2018)

Apocalypse Now of the American West. A completely different western, and gorgeous. A structure based on Coppola's legend that takes you through a thematic landscape in search of epiphany and awareness, with great performances, a tender yet unsettling minimalist soundtrack and unprecedented spiritual depth, and an ending that will make you want to cry together with the protagonists. The filmmaking is deliberately austere, but Cooper scores again with a sensitive narrative that, while slow, can hardly be faulted in terms of the key emphasis on the interactions between the characters and the overall critical portrayal of America's ugly phase at the time. Perhaps there could have been fewer of those puzzling scenes by the fire and the development of the relationship between the captain and the chief is too fast, but this has no effect on the overall emotional and mental catharsis. How the hell didn't this have any Oscar nominations?!! (02/10/2018)

Hostiles est un western rude qui relate la quête d’un respect mutuel entre deux combattants suivant une démarche engagée politiquement (à l’instar du film Il faut sauver le soldat Ryan). Étonnamment, de nombreux parallèles peuvent être établis avec un autre western moderne, 3 h 10 pour Yuma, tant pour la structure du récit que pour son ambiance similaire, ou encore la participation des acteurs Christian Bale et Ben Foster. Pour le reste, Hostiles suit, sur un tempo lent, une route bien à lui qui ne manque pas de captiver le spectateur. La réalisation de Scott Cooper est excellente. Présentée différemment, La scène dans laquelle Metz (Rory Cochrane) s’agenouille devant la tente du chef aurait pu être terriblement cliché, mais, grâce au remarquable jeu d’acteurs et à la manière dont Cooper a fait les choses, elle constitue le moment fort du film. [KVIFF 2018] (08/07/2018)

Un western pur et dur avec une intrigue captivante et magnifiquement écrite, une réalisation fantastique et des acteurs brillants - les rumeurs sur la performance de Christian Bale ne mentaient pas, bien que l'on puisse discuter de savoir si c'est sa meilleure performance (mais c'est certainement dans le top 3 et il est incroyable de voir à quel point Bale joue magnifiquement avec ses yeux, ses sourcils, les rides sur son front et sa moustache). En revanche, il ne fait aucun doute que Rosamund Pike livre la meilleure performance. Son personnage tragique allie à la fois fragilité et force, alors que le héros de Bale est un guerrier tout aussi tragique, dont les compagnons d'armes disparaissent progressivement dans un environnement impitoyable. Le film est empli de thèmes forts et graves, allant des débats sur la violence, la nature humaine et la morale, au poids de la conscience et aux différences entre tuer par ordre et tuer en général. Une atmosphère majestueuse, des émotions, des personnages brillamment écrits, un travail parfait sur les motifs, les quatre dernières minutes peuvent paraître un peu trop douces, mais sont en fait logiques. Les Indiens ne sont pas tous les mêmes. Un vrai chef-d'œuvre. (02/07/2018)

Christian Bale is a sure bet for me, which was confirmed to me yet again. I had trouble sympathizing with the rancher family from the opening scene. If a bunch of people settled on my land and declared it their property, I wouldn't be open to discussion either, but Bale's racist Captain Blocker was excellent. The whole trip to Montana would have been mind-numbingly boring, but fortunately for the viewer and, unfortunately for those involved, it was disrupted by occasional violent events. The atmosphere was properly dismal, and the guardians of world democracy once again showed themselves in their true light, so I was almost completely satisfied. The only thing that spoiled my overall impression a little was the ending. (13/09/2018)

While this damn honest and extremely well-scripted Scott Cooper masterpiece has very modest production design, it is spectacular in the truest sense of the word. Christian Bale is perhaps the greatest actor of his generation, and he delivers an utterly crushing yet endearing performance here. The fact that much of the story is largely shaped by the post-traumatic stress of the character played by Rosamund Pike is used to absolutely bravura effect, and even though Rosamund Pike barely speaks here, most of her scenes are powerful as hell, thanks to a terrific and extremely sensitive script. It's incredible how much Scott Cooper manages to "cover" in those 134 minutes of screenwriting, but not a single second here feels superfluous. It's the kind of small big film that can't, by definition, succeed in the mainstream, but which is a huge treat for the properly attuned viewer. [90%] (09/02/2022)