Master & Commander : De l'autre côté du monde

N'importe ce que vous attendez, vous obtiendrez quelque chose de différent. Master & Commander est comme James Ivory sur l'eau. Sans intrigue de gros film, sans action, sans grands héros. Une excursion psychologique dans la vie de l'équipage d'un vieux navire de guerre, de ses conflits personnels et des règles qu'il doit suivre. La scène la plus lumineuse dans ce film de guerre serait la bataille finale réussie. Ici, il s'agit de la collecte de scarabées par un médecin blessé sur une île tropicale. Une belle caméra, avec des dizaines de nuances détaillées dépeignant les caractères des différents personnages. Russell Crowe apparaît à l'écran et vous l'adorez immédiatement. Et vous développez une relation avec les autres personnages principaux, comme si vous les connaissiez depuis des années. Peter Weir est un réalisateur unique. (13/11/2003)

Thanks to the engaging filmmaking and realistic setting, I can safely say: I was there with them. On the ship during the storm, during the battles and during the moments of relaxation, and I was not bored at all. In the opening battle I was thrown into the whirlwind of the action, with blood, sweat and tears at my fingertips, during the scene with the crashing my ship was being tossed from side to side, and on the Galapagos I relaxed with the Doctor to the strains of the double bass and it was enjoyable. If Weir wanted to show a detailed portrait of life on an English battleship, he succeeded. If he wanted to make an adventure story, he certainly didn't miss. And certainly not with this select ensemble of actors. I believed Crowe and Bettany and their captain and doctor, respectively, every second. And by the way, do you want to know how a scarecrow can help win a naval battle? Then don't hesitate with this film. (30/06/2004)

Monumentally grand, beautifully shot, bombastically scored, and masterfully acted... Although the plot may be somewhat simple, it serves as a perfect microcosm of the life of an ordinary ship's crew, likely one of the most comprehensive portrayals available in today's mainstream oceans. (01/07/2004)

I can't remember the last time I found out before the movie climaxed that I had barely been breathing. It had to be a long time ago, and it had to be for a movie similar to Master and Commander. This is a wonderful callback to old times, robust filmmaking with a clear vision, precise leadership and superbly put together dramatic layers. Peter Weir has commanding skills and the steadfastness of captain Jack, but he also remains an analytical observer like Dr. Stephen. The way individual characters are built, and the way chemistry is maintained by the crew, should be in a cinematic tactics textbook. In a few minutes, a person is on board and participates in a cruise that is both informative, exciting and emotional. Moreover, Weir's typical dualities of small and large universes are reflected here, when war, politics, and science are all reflected in the relationships and conversations of the characters, without the film sliding into any exaggerated philosophizing. Everything's just right, and the dust won't get wet despite the thunderous runtime. This blew off my main mast. Huzzah! (and the second part, from what Peter Weir told us, is not utopia). (03/04/2011)

A perfect combination of artsy chamber piece focused on characters and “how things worked on those beautiful vessels with sails" with a simple adventure for boys about friendship and duties like out of a dime novel you read secretly during lessons. Despite having nothing whatsoever to do with the equally marvelous book the movie is based on (this is more a mixture of the first and third book with a bit from the tenth book in the Aubrey and Maturin series), this is a simply wonderful movie in its sense for historical precision, characterization of characters or nods for readers (Jack’s missing earlobe, letters to Sophia, Maturin’s “floral" waistcoat etc.) And technical aspects keep step with the content - they are the highest possible standard. The only thing that disappoints me is the non-existence of a director’s cut. As a whole twenty-four minutes of cut scenes demonstrates, not just ballast, but much high quality material was left out of the final cut. (28/01/2007)

I can't even believe how sensitively such a one-sided issue can be portrayed. For two hours, I wanted to serve on the Surprise under the perfect captain Crowe and fight for England. It's a shame that the script can't adapt to Weir's fantastic directing and sometimes slips into completely unnecessary twists, like in the case of the superstition about Jonah. (17/07/2007)

In terms of its production quality, Master & Commander is a spellbindingly impressive project that’s beautifully anachronistic in relation to the trends of the time when it was released. Because of that, however, it inevitably fell short of box-office expectations and failed to become the start of a film franchise, but that doesn’t change the fact that its qualities have stood the test of time. Especially today, when digital effects have long since lost their wow effect, the stubborn authenticity on display here is breathtaking in its immediacy and physicality. In line with the book series whose name the film bears, the narrative focuses on depicting the battleship as an organism and all aspects of life throughout the hierarchy of its crew. To heighten the drama, the individual peripeteias represent the best of the events of the naval battles. The ingeniously constructed screenplay flawlessly connects the two storylines. To the same effect, the individual cut sequences and dolly shots help to map the topography of the ship while constantly illustrating the real dimension of both ordinary tasks and the chaos of battle. (22/07/2023)

For a large part of its runtime, Master and Commander maintains an excellent five-star level of unconventional drama, which does without typical genre clichés and is characterized by a decent atmosphere. The director is not as interested in the war action as in depicting the life of a sailboat crew at the beginning of the 19th century, and through minor incidents and dialogues, the viewer learns a lot not only about a sailor's life but also about the whole society of that time. Among other things, it is a film about friendship and responsibility and a hierarchy of values. The final third of the film, which portrays the clash of two warships, is predictable, clichéd, and above all poorly shot, as well as fragmented, chaotic, and poorly edited. Peter Weir simply doesn't know how to do this, it's not his area of expertise. The culmination of the film for me was not the battle frenzy, but several dialogues between the captain and his ship's doctor. Overall impression: 80%. The film has an excellent cast, with Russell Crowe excelling in his role. In addition to the cast, the film's strengths include the authenticity of the setting and the cinematography, which utilizes all the possibilities that the ocean environment provides. (26/08/2008)

Master and Commander is a picture not so much about great sea battles, but more a study on Captain “happy Jack" Aubrey. Peter Weir’s ingenious direction is aided by the great Russell Crowe and the no less excellent Paul Bettany. Wonderful shots of the sea alternate with the amazing wildlife of the Galapagos. I found the music very powerful. (02/09/2007)

There are few historical blockbusters full of epic battles that can be called realistic, and Master and Commander is one of the exceptions. It is an ambitiously and maturely crafted film in every aspect, with phenomenal technical execution and skillfully condensed in terms of plot. (12/12/2003)

Au ciné, il m’est arrivé de m’endormir sur trois films : The Game, Batman Begins et Master & Commander. J’adore Russel Crowe, mais je ne comprends pas comment il a pu se prêter à un scénario aussi médiocre. Un navire poursuit l’autre au bout du monde puis, à la fin, ils se rencontrent et c’est parti pour une grande pagaille ! Plus jamais, même sous la torture ! (06/06/2007)

This is no idyll on a yacht, there's no love line, no picturesque sunsets, no heroic ending, just the open ocean and two wooden boats. Weir's Master & Commander is a cinematic phenomenon that was as close to reality as we've ever seen in historical films, but this doesn’t mean that it is a live-action documentary. In addition to a great cast, the film also features a lavish production design, which also proves the enormous costliness of nautical films. It is therefore difficult to ever see the real highlights of the Napoleonic Wars, such as Trafalgar, the Nile and the whole life of the famous British Admiral Horatio Nelson. (03/03/2016)