The Finest Hours

Une version action du romantique The Notebook (!) sur les sauveteurs de guerre dans l'océan hivernal agité ? Les gars en doudounes d'hiver, à bord d'un bateau à moteur ouvert de 1952, naviguent à travers d'énormes vagues (comme plongeant sous l'eau) de l'océan hivernal avec une température juste au-dessus de zéro, à la recherche des survivants piégés d'un naufrage. Les seuls moments de tension lors de cette course effrénée surviennent lorsque nous glissons du bateau naufragé par une échelle - bien que nous devrions avoir constamment peur pour chaque personnage, en compatissant avec la jeune femme sur la terre ferme qui ne veut pas perdre sa moitié bien-aimée. Cependant, le film ne parvient pas à transmettre cela, il ne sait pas quoi faire avec les personnages et leur motivation, et la seule saveur qu'il laisse est une belle stylisation rétro romantique. JEREMIE (04/10/2018)

A film that is absolutely breathless, toiling like a barge on a stormy sea. The subdued and skilled camera technically stands up, but what is the point when the actors act between the naivety of the 1950s and the misinterpretations of Shakespeare (especially nominate Hamlet from Casey Affleck's engine room for the Golden Raspberry)? Wooden dialogues, a very vague structure and de facto the only exciting scene (overcoming the surf on the way from the port) result in probably the most boring disaster film, in which the film itself is the biggest disaster. The only thing that deserves some recognition is that Gillespie is trying a more civil approach than, for example, Wolfgang Petersen in The Perfect Storm... but what's the point when nothing but stupor comes from the film? (28/01/2016)

I had no idea if this appealing sea adventure was a true story or the creation of the writers, so I was pleasantly surprised and, within the limits of a "family disaster movie", even found myself in a state of suspense in places. Of course, it's no Perfect Storm, but even so, the rating here seems unfairly low, because many of the scenes are truly memorable –crossing and riding huge waves, steering a half-broken tanker (that long shot of the passing of the order, backed by Burwell's music, is great), the arrival at the port... It's just a pity they didn't work more on the storyline involving Webber's fiancée, which was almost unnecessary in all this. (26/12/2019)

"To the last breath" is not a movie that made an impression on me. Perhaps, if I watched it with my girlfriend, both of us being relaxed and just wanting to unwind, I would be in the mood for it. But this time, the straightforwardness of Disney simply didn't get to me. The story didn't entertain or interest me overall, maybe only the water scenes were beautifully done. (05/05/2016)

After Deepwater Horizon, it’s really tough to give this Disney crap a better review than two water test valves. The reason why I’m comparing these is that what Deepwater Horizon has in common with this flick is the story, water and the link to the disaster is more than obvious as well. But what’s more important is that the real disaster was taken care of here by digital effects and the characters are laughable and they would almost make you cry rather than provide a serious emotional basis for a good quality emotional experience. The Finest Hour is simply a bad film and on top of that it might be the first serious Disney movie. In this case, it’s a very bad Disney movie, which I think should be aired on Disney Channel on Sunday after lunch. But it definitely doesn’t deserve to be shown in cinemas. (10/10/2016)