Carnage

Avec Vendredi 13 et Massacre au camp d'été, ce film pourrait compléter la trilogie imaginaire des meilleurs camp slashers des années 80. Bien qu’il puise pas mal d’idées dans les films cités plus haut – le premier en particulier –, Carnage emprunte sa propre voie et recèle quelques scènes bien épicées. Très correct. (22/04/2018)

Tuerie ennuyeuse, l'une des réponses les plus connues à Vendredi 13. Un mannequin brûlé avec des cisailles de jardin massacre des adolescents dans un camp. Après un début prometteur, la première moitié est ennuyeuse et il ne se passe pratiquement rien, suivie d'un règlement de comptes avec des scènes sanglantes agréables. Le film a été interdit dans de nombreux pays en raison de ces scènes. Dans l'ensemble, le film n'a rien d'exceptionnel. Des dialogues stupides et une musique de synthétiseur de série B. Vendredi 13 était plus professionnel du point de vue de la production. Le début des jeunes passionnés de cinéma (scénario + production) Harvey et Bob Weinstein. Holly Hunter apparaît brièvement pendant deux secondes. (30/12/2003)

Slasher is not and have never been my favourite subgenre, I get them all mixed up after some time, but I quite liked this one. In fact, I’m surprised The Burning never got a sequel, it has a decent villain for that. The murders are all committed with garden shears, but I don’t think the result is very good, they all look very similar – with the exception of the scene on the raft – I will remember that one for a long time. The atmosphere is effective, especially at the beginning and by the end, while the first half could have a richer plot, but it’s bearable. The Burning is a decent representative of the camp slashers from the 80s, no more than that. (18/08/2008)

Carol Clover shed a lot of tears over The Burning. The influential film theorist came up with the now widely used concept of the final girl and established the slasher as a subgenre that positively lends itself to the feminist viewpoint. Subsequent studies, such as Richard Nowell’s work, demonstrate that slasher producers, in response to the market of the time, also absolutely counted on a female audience and thus deliberately populated the genre with active female protagonists and constituent motifs that resonated with the female part of the audience. Opposed to this contemporary context, The Burning presents a fetishistically violent and fiercely misogynistic counterpoint. As such, the film defies causality and internal logic, but it is held together by its disdain for and objectification of women. The girls at the co-ed summer camp are viewed through a voyeur’s lens and emerge from their individual situations primarily as whores who make a lot of fuss and all they think about is sex. The central killer is supposed to be driven by a desire for revenge for the horrific burns inflicted on him by a group of privileged boys, which he satisfies by mainly killing the girls rather than dispatching the macho bullies at the camp. Could all of this somehow be related to the fact that this flick was written and produced by Harvey Weinstein? (04/04/2021)