Paranoiak

Accuser Disturbia de se baser sur le scénario de thriller le plus recyclé et de ne pas apporter le moindre moment de surprise serait injuste. C'est un suspens bien maîtrisé dans le métier pour les adolescents qui ont volé les concepts de "Hitchcock" ou "Fenêtre sur cour". Shia LaBeouf porte dignement toute la première heure, un peu ennuyeuse, sur ses épaules et Sarah Roemer rappelle les moments de collège des premiers amours. Et les 20 dernières minutes sont vraiment intenses. (11/07/2007)

It begins as a decent teenage comedy that in the second half turns into a thriller that pulls you a bit into the story. Shia has a quite a lot of talent, he carries this film on his shoulders all the way to an above-average rating. (24/12/2007)

D.J. Caruso may not be in the category of directorial geniuses, but Temporary is honestly made craft, with a decent script (with a notorious theme since 1954) and especially a fantastic Shia LaBeouf. There hasn't been a teenager with such a flexible range of acting abilities in years. A likable film worth a Single watch that proves that even teen movies can be entertaining and clever at the same time. (28/09/2007)

I don't know why Shia LaBeouf seems so scared and unshaven in all his movies, but maybe that's why I enjoy his movies in the end. In the beginning the movie seemed to me like "Home Alone for Grownups", gradually the movie picked up momentum and by the end I probably couldn’t even catch my breath. (28/10/2010)

Disturbia is a combination of the thriller classic Rear Window and the independent film Cherish, presented in teenage packaging. This is a case where lively and high-quality direction surpasses the average script containing inconsistencies and unfinished elements. It is precisely because of the direction and casting that I ultimately lean toward giving it four stars, even though scenes such as when the protagonist fearlessly enters a house, knowing that he will inevitably confront a brutal serial killer who is significantly bigger, stronger, and experienced in the field, evoke a indulgent smile from me. I believe that you would do the same as him, but I would prefer to provoke the neighbors and the police. Overall impression: 70%. (26/11/2010)

For me personally, this was a bit of a test for Shia LaBeouf to see if he really is that good even without "giant fucking robots" covering his back. And it seems that he is. So I hope that he will carry on in this vein. P:S: Sarah Roemer is the second best looking fox on the silver screen this year. (17/09/2007)

Disturbia fulfills the parameters of a thriller concept down to the last detail, and elevates the acting of the captivating teenager Shia LaBeouf to above-average levels. If this boy started to finally play a man and stopped fooling around in front of the screen and pretending to be younger, it would be even better. Nevertheless, there is still plenty to watch. The first hour is relatively slow, with detailed character development and several funny and awkward situations. The second half and the final climax are a bit different, but surprisingly, the contrast between the two parts works quite well. D.J. Caruso directs inventively and tries to keep the viewer on guard. The opening accident and the final scenes in the basement are excellent. Otherwise, it is an above-average genre film. (12/04/2008)

Au début, ça ressemblait à un drame psychologique, ensuite à une comédie pour ados, puis à un thriller tendu et, pour finir, à un mélange de tous ces styles. :) Quoi qu’il en soit, j’ai passé un bon moment et je laisse une évaluation positive. (09/12/2007)

When a thriller is made by a director who discovers in the process of making it that he doesn't actually want to make a thriller, it's a bummer. I guess that's why Disturbia looks more like a boring demo of interior lighting options. It's like Transformers without the robots. Shia running around, acting completely irrational, confused, stuttering, well just "cuuuute". Yet he picks up the biggest slut in the western hemisphere through the most depraved method – stalking, taking off her bra, peeing in her swimsuit and so forth. Girls, if that's your thing... be my guest. In its detective moments, the film acts more like a parody – the final thunderstorm with no rain, the electricity working one day, going out the other, the cop who's otherwise at the house within three seconds decides to just fuck off and finish his burger. The ultimate collection of genre clichés and teenage boredom with decent direction. A thriller for the whole family. (03/12/2011)