The Punisher

Le Punisher n'est pas ce qu'il prétend être dans la bande-annonce, ni ce qu'il semble être sur les photos. Ce n'est pas une BD d'action sombre et visuellement attrayante sur une grande vengeance. Il y a certes une vengeance, mais les façons dont le scénariste et le réalisateur Jonathan Hensleigh la présentent commencent avec des clichés de Seagal et se poursuivent avec une série de répliques bon marché et une parodie involontaire de soi-même. La seule chose qui peut être appréciée dans le film est l'élimination inattendue et amusante des méchants. (30/04/2004)

The main reason why The Punisher failed is the script. It fails not only with poorly written dialogues but also with a weak plot. The relatively solid cast – Thomas Jane, John Travolta, Will Patton, Samantha Mathis, and Rebecca Romijn – is wasted. If the film had been in the hands of someone like Tony Scott or John Woo, it could have been a top-notch gritty action ride. As it stands, however, it is just an ordinary action movie, of which we can see hundreds if not thousands these days. (08/12/2004)

When the best thing about a whole movie is the main character's shirt, something is wrong. To be fair, though, there are two scenes that make this nonsense is survivable: the initial disposal of Castle's family has a certain amount of impact, and the fight with the Russian muscle-head to the accompaniment of an operatic aria, which is not without its comic exaggeration. The rest, full of ridiculous, pathetic poses, does not do credit to the creators, nor to the fluffy and dynamic comic book premise itself. Although I think Travolta shouldn't climb in front of the camera anymore, here he was mysteriously tolerable, while the mediocre Thomas Jane might not need a Shakespearean training for such a role, but I resisted the onslaught of my diaphragm every time I saw his badass face. But during the scene when the elevator goes up and there's Thomas turning on it, with a taut body under his tattered tank top and a harsh look on his face, I burst out laughing, I really couldn't help it :) (14/07/2007)

“We aren’t just happy, we’re crazy! " Well, I understand why The Punisher became a cult movie in certain circles. An ingeniously bad movie. You need a real big does of talent to film something... like this. After just a couple of minutes of watching, you will tell yourself that it couldn’t be any stupider. But the opposite applies, unfortunately. Every word is outrageously bad. The Punisher is a movie that you won’t forget for a long time and one that will always brighten your day. So what if the effect is completely different than intended by the creators? (01/11/2007)