Pearl

Un Joker au féminin. Aussi intéressant, psychologiquement construit avec soin et cinématographiquement raffiné, que le profil d'un asocial instable qui dépasse les limites, comme l'a été le film acclamé avec Joaquin Phoenix. L'environnement d'une famille de « Hillbilly » dans une maison de la campagne Texane m'est encore plus proche. Ti West suggère ici de manière idyllique à quoi pouvaient ressembler les débuts d'autres familles texanes célèbres... La stylisation rétro kitsch contraste avec les tons sombres de la bande sonore, suggère la présence du mal caché et laisse progressivement éclater son explosion. Le personnage principal ravit les fans du genre non seulement avec une fourche ou une hache en main, mais aussi par un long monologue sur sa propre déchirure mentale. Mia Goth est remarquable. Et ces éclairs audiovisuels à la Kubrick et Hitchcock... un plaisir formel pour les intéressés. (06/11/2022)

Some people say that a film is as good as its villain, and, Pearl is a perfect example. Mia Goth is amazing, on a small space she can play a naive girl, a broken woman, a demon-ridden bitch and a total psychopath, she has all of that in her acting register. Her almost ten-minute confession at the end, filmed in one take, blew my mind. Moreover, it's all supported by a script that flows naturally, has a logical development and almost reaches the level of Phoenix's Joker in terms of psychology. And the visual games with the camera, the opening with classical music in the style of good old Hollywood! I'm just shocked that after the botched X, Ti West was able to create something like this. This is a little horror treat, made with love and art, aimed at film connoisseurs. (26/06/2023)

A treat, but be prepared for it to be a completely different film than X. While the first film in the series referenced dirty exploitation classics, this one is more of a beautifully colourful naive drama, with nasty perversion and depravity bubbling under the surface. Mia Goth in the lead role is great, pulling it off with aplomb, the clear highlight of the film being her lengthy monologue shortly before the end. For me, compared to X, weaker as horror, but better as a film. (21/10/2022)

After the great X comes a steep fall that leaves bitter aftertaste. Ti West isn't my favourite director, in fact X is the only film I liked from him, so I was definitely curious about the prequel and the original villains, and the rave reviews overseas indicated it was going to be a hit, but here comes quite a disappointment. It's a bit hard to judge because Pearl definitely has its qualities, but from a horror perspective it's a big bummer. X gave a flashback to the hixploitation films of a bygone era, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre in particular came to mind for everyone, it had juicy gore, creepy bad guys and soft porn in the first half. Pearl unfortunately has none of that and goes in a different direction, which will no doubt disappoint most viewers. Let's summarize the pros first. The setting in the wartime period of 1918 is nice, a very unusual time for a horror film, so welcome. Mia Goth gives the performance of a lifetime, she's good, psychologically disturbed, believable and able to command attention. The dialogue is also engaging and the cinematography isn't bad either, but that's it unfortunately. If this was a drama, it would be a decent film that is well made and acted, but horror fans will get nothing here. No hint of atmosphere, no gore?!! Okay, that one scene at the end it’s not enough. It's neither creepy nor dark, in fact ‘horror’ seems to me to be a misnomer. It's a psychological study of a disturbed girl in an unconventional period and if you accept that you might be OK, but for my taste it was a heavy slow burn drama and I certainly not what I was expecting. The five-minute monologue and the family dinner during the storm (quite possibly the best scene of the film) was interesting. 5/10. (21/10/2022)

Ti West, après X, slasher rétro assez réussi, nous offre un technicolor cauchemardesque qui fonctionne parfaitement dans son habit kitch (volontaire). Pearl, contrairement à son film précédent, est imprévisible et s’écarte des tendances du genre. Et Mia Goth confirme une fois de plus qu'elle est une force incroyablement énergique dans le cinéma de genre actuel. (28/05/2023)

X wasn't exactly stellar, so I didn't set my expectations high for this prequel, only to be pleasantly surprised in the end. While I can't say I was thrilled, I must admit that Ti West delivered a significantly better piece of work this time. I hesitate to label this movie as a horror with a clear conscience; it felt more like a dive into the psyche of an unconventional American country girl, struggling with her ambitions and other issues. Not that she put much effort into fighting them back, mind you. There was definitely an improvement compared to the previous/next film, mainly because I didn't feel the need to hit the fast-forward button this time. I wonder if Mia Goth's involvement in the screenplay contributed to this improvement; it certainly seemed that way from my perspective. But who's to say for sure, right? I would easily tack on an extra star, but the creators shouldn't be so overconfident. They really ought to bring in some advisors on handling an axe during filming. Watching Pearl, who's supposedly lived her whole life on a farm, handle an axe like a virgin was painful. The same person could probably explain to the crew that an axe blade leaves distinct marks on the human body, unlike those made by a surgical saw. Yep, the devil's in the details. / Lesson learned: If you're using farm tools to chase your dreams, you're probably going too far. (27/10/2023)

While West's previous film X leaned on the atmosphere of 70s slasher and porn films, its prequel Pearl is a homage to classic Hollywood, combining the dark tale of the protagonist's descent into madness with the aesthetics of colourful Technicolor melodramas and live-action Disney films from the 50s. It features a boisterous orchestral score, overwrought musical numbers and artificially picturesque scenery, but it also gradually breaks down Hollywood glitz and subverts the conventions of the aforementioned films, like in the the way the main character treats the animals. The story can be seen as a wacky variation on The Wizard of Oz. Pearl is a lonely farmer girl who dances and talks to the animals on a fairy-tale farm and dreams of becoming a big Hollywood star instead of cleaning up cow poop. But circumstances force her to stay in a depressing reality (and have sex with a scarecrow in a field). Over time, her unfulfilled fairy-tale dreams of a world "over the rainbow" have terrifying consequences, and Pearl transforms from "Dorothy" to "the Wicked Witch." This is no gorefest full of scares, but an old-fashioned psychodrama with long takes and carefully crafted mise-en-scene. The film has even been praised by Martin Scorsese himself, who has said that the love of cinema can be felt in every frame. And it really is a treat for cinephiles. The main driving force is once again Mia Goth's performance. Her ability to play a seamless transition from a sweetly naive farm girl to a bloodthirsty murderous psychopath is unparalleled. The climactic final scene then builds to her long monologue, which is shot almost entirely in one unbroken take. (16/11/2023)