Pas de printemps pour Marnie

Une musique magnifique et passionnée de Bernard Herrmann et de bonnes performances d'acteurs, mais la fusion de l'histoire d'amour et du thriller coince. L'essence de l'histoire de Hitchcock a étonnamment glissé entre les doigts. (29/11/2004)

I probably never expected to find an adaptation of Winston Graham (otherwise the creator of the Poldark series) in Hitchcock's filmography. But it happened, and Hitchcock needed material for another film with Tippi Hedren, whom he was currently interested in. What more can I say? From The Birds onwards, Hitchcock was no longer enjoyable and his films were increasingly over the top. Marnie is just another improbable story that Hitchcock had rewritten so that he could play with his next Barbie. There’s no special experience to be had, and the styling, costumes, and make-up are at times unbearable (especially Connery's eyebrows). (12/01/2020)

A very good psychological drama with some amazing scenes (in addition to the robbery, of course, the nerve-wracking ending with the horse and everything that comes after), an excellent performance by Tippi Hedren and a 100% romantic score by Bernard Herrmann. But if Marnie had been some 20 minutes shorter, I would have rated it even better. (19/05/2016)