I... comme Icare

Il est amusant de constater que les termes « thriller politique avec Yves Montand » désignent pratiquement un sous-genre à part entière au sein du cinéma français. Parmi le paquet d’œuvres très attachantes et de qualité qui en découlent, celle-ci en fait incontestablement partie. D’un point de vue structurel, I… comme Icare est un thriller intéressant. Il expose à plusieurs reprises, et de façon assez directe, le contexte du crime politique en toile de fond – chaque fois avec un angle d’attaque original, un suspense palpitant et, en même temps, un aspect très instructif, scolaire. Un spectateur averti peut voir venir la fin incisive, mais cela n’enlève absolument rien à l’impact du film. (29/11/2021)

The investigation of the JFK assassination without JFK. The apparent similarity, or what Vian says in the opening of the film, that just because it apparently didn’t happen doesn’t mean that it could not have happened that way, is not coincidental. Leaving aside that conspiracy angle on the JFK realities, even purely on its own it's a disturbing, detached procedural thriller par excellence. The most famous passage is the chilling performance of the Milgram experiment; and rightly so. A proven "Verneuil" genre quality that has lost none of its relevance. (22/10/2022)

Although I really like some of his directorial work, I generally have a problem with Henri Verneuil, I usually find his films quite naive with a logic that often takes a holiday. This is the case here, too, unfortunately, and I found the much-praised scientific experiment naive; and the lure of Morricone was absolutely untapped. My attention in this cold, verbose procedural was held only by my favourite Yves Montand, who was never a Belmondo or Delon type star, but his charisma and acting skills were unquestionable (e.g. he was absolutely riveting in The Confession). And the final twist? Well... it didn’t knock me down, but that ending IS impressive. (12/01/2022)