The Neon Demon

"La beauté n'est pas tout. C'est la seule chose." Magnifiques génériques d'ouverture et de clôture. Et ce n'est pas seulement grâce à Martinez, qui se profile dans la ligue des compositeurs du futur. Mais l'enthousiasme s'arrête là. Ce serait dommage si nous arrêtions de nous réjouir des films de Refn et si nous n'y étions que curieux. Comme s'il essayait d'atteindre cela, en oubliant que le plus grand succès pour lui (pas seulement à Cannes) a été l'histoire avec du cœur (Drive), mise en valeur par une réalisation unique. Et pas seulement la réalisation elle-même. The Neon Demon est un film simple avec une idée claire. Ce n'est pas une énigme pour une discussion intellectuelle excitante, comme l'était Only God Forgives dans une certaine mesure. Et dans cette transparence et cette prévisibilité, il remplace la possibilité de ressentir l'histoire par une narration purement visuelle, visuellement attrayante. Et il laisse le spectateur froid et impassible. Mais vous devez le voir, ne serait-ce que pour le baiser gluant sur le cadavre que nous n'avons pas encore vu dans la production américaine. [Cannes] (20/05/2016)

Refn is one of those directors that I always wished would make a horror film. The announcement of Neon Demon fulfilled one of my dreams as a cinemagoer and the expectations couldn’t have been higher. After the responses from the première in Cannes, I still believed the film will grip and captivate me instead of sending me to the other side of the fence, with the disgusted and annoyed viewers. But in the end it was worse – it was just meh! Boring. It didn’t arouse any emotions, positive or negative. Audiovisually, it’s beautifully empty. (12/09/2016)

After I watched this movie, I’ve got the feeling that Nicolas Winding Refn is drowning in his own filmmaking utopias. I get that the Neon Demon has a clear premise about modelling, but I don’t get the artistic pathos they’re using to get to the point. Sure, many of the scenes are very interesting and very pleasing to the eye, but as a whole, I feel like the movie’s just a concurrence of different scenes that don’t make much sense. The director’s lucky that he can choose the right music to his video. I fell for it with Drive, but it was a bit harder this time. (22/11/2016)

Pubertal provocation. Refn was able to show the depth of the surface in such a way that a similar emptied mess full of dull script clichés could hardly upset a person. In addition, NRW directs poorly this time. Wooden dialogues, clip sequences that every little talented advertising director can handle, whilst the great Elle and Cliff Martinez's electro-arpeggio take care of all the dynamics. I was expecting hypnosis, but this is a sedative. [Cannes 2016] (20/05/2016)

A non-mainstream, visually captivating, hypnotically immersive experience for those who can appreciate Nicolas Winding Refn's extraordinary visual sensibilities. But Refn is also explicitly provocative, completely unnecessarily so, and I could really do without a few scenes (sex in the morgue, yuck!). So when I add up the pros and cons, Refn ends up with a draw, but the kid has talent for more, much more. That's probably how Jaromil Jireš would shoot it when he was making Valerie and Her Week of Wonders, he would be a bit of a pervert and permanently on drugs. (06/10/2016)