Résumés(1)

La Sénatrice Dianne Feinstein confie à son nouvel employé la tâche d’enquêter sur les méthodes d’interrogation de la CIA suite aux attentats du 11 septembre. Peu avant, des centaines d’heures d’enregistrement de terroristes potentiels sont éliminés par la CIA. Dans une cave, Jones et ses collaborateurs se mettent alors à éplucher des tonnes de dossiers et de documents pour mettre la lumière sur les dénommées techniques d’interrogatoire renforcées. Dans le cadre de leurs recherches, ils tombent sur des pratiques brutales, totalement inutiles du reste. Mais avant que Jones et Feinstein rendent le résultat de leurs recherches public, la CIA et la Maison Blanche feront tout pour leur mettre des bâtons dans les roues et empêcher la publication par tous les moyens possibles et imaginables… The Report est un thriller politique prenant qui, sans aucun effet spectaculaire mais grâce au talent d’Adam Driver, nous entraîne dans un gigantesque tourbillon. (Zurich Film Festival)

(plus)

Critiques (3)

DaViD´82 

Toutes les critiques de l’utilisateur·trice

anglais A reserved pure bureaucratic procedure “names-dates-facts-dates-names", which recapitulates some six years of way to detailed work. Nowhere is there even a hint of anything personal, as all dialogues, dilemmas and actions of everyone revolve only around the compilation, promotion, political (non) acceptance, (non) acceptance and (mis) recognition of the results of the central analysis, whose conclusions test and sharpen the sharpest edges of the law and transform them into information / responsibility / the boundaries of democracy / political power / understandable pragmatism, etc. I said already it is a pure procedural movie. And a damn good one. Thy only problem is that Burns is a little bit lost in terms to what extent of details the movie should go into. So, at one point he literally investigates how much sugar XY put in his coffee at a specific meeting, while after that he describes the course of few months/years in just one sentence. And this is true until the moment when the report of about seven thousand pages is written, and a more tangible and fun phase of “this must / must not be published" both in terms of direction and script will start. ()

3DD!3 

Toutes les critiques de l’utilisateur·trice

anglais Fascinating. America accuses itself of crimes against humanity. This procedural dialogue-based movie with the dogged Driver has drive and an unexpected outcome (luckily with a closing title showing that justice will not be served in any case) even though it’s based on actual events. The Report is admirably convincing with raw flashbacks showing enhanced interrogation techniques in practice, which just serve to emphasize the message that, thanks to this film, we don’t have to read the 7,000-page torture report to find out. P.S: I liked the reference to Jack Bauer. ()

Necrotongue 

Toutes les critiques de l’utilisateur·trice

anglais This is not the first film criticizing the foreign policy of the US (and their closest allies) that I’ve seen recently. Official Secrets, which I saw earlier, was slightly better in comparison, as there was certainly more action. The Report seemed somewhat dry to me. I do understand that it is difficult to produce an action thriller out of a giant pile of papers and a windowless basement room, but still... I have never liked inquisition practices and I don't like religious fanatics either (it kind of goes hand in hand) and I have no idea why Americans were so surprised when they had to face terrorist attacks. After all, it was they, along with the Soviets, who supplied weapons to every kind of war on the planet just to gain more influence than their opponents. Now it’s coming back to bite them in the ass. It also goes to show that the Nuremberg trial was just a farce. There is no prospect of improvement. Despite having all the key information, the Americans still elect Big Mouth into the Oval Office. 4*- ()