La Méthode Williams

Je suis le tennis de haut niveau depuis que je suis enfant et n'ai jamais eu les sœurs Williams en sympathie. Au contraire, elles ont toujours eu l'art de m'irriter par leurs manières et leur style de jeu. Et naturellement, cette perception que j'ai d'elles se reflète dans mon appréciation de ce film. Ainsi, je ne supporte pas la scène où leur père leur apprend l'humilité, une humilité dont ni l'une ni l'autre n'a absolument jamais fait preuve, que ce soit avant, pendant ou après un match. Elles se sont toujours vues et se verront toujours comme les meilleures de l'histoire, même si Serena ne réalisera probablement plus le Grand Chelem. Si quelqu'un faisait un film sur Justine Henin ou sur Patty Schnyder, je serais preneur. Et Will Smith ? Il s'agit sans aucun doute d'une performance d'acteur non conventionnelle de sa part, mais ça me semble peu de chose pour un Oscar. (09/03/2022)

I like these bottoms-to-top sports dramas a lot, and this one definitely ranks as one of my favorites. Will Smith is perfect, his life wisdom and advice are a balm to the soul, the emotions are functional, the dramatic scenes are steamy (the police visit was great), and the tennis scenes were entertaining. A powerful and incredible story. I enjoyed it more than I would have hoped. 8/10. (31/12/2021)

Serena and Venus as the perfect projects of the brilliant strategist and visionary Richard. Nothing against it, but the film is too respectful of the King's gloriole. Although it tries to problematize his motivations and the execution of the divine plan for the "two Jordans" several times, it always ends up slipping into schematic adoration. Green isn't an inventive director. He just repeats a learned pattern of punches and when he has to do a big smash at the end to win the game, he hits it out of bounds. Partly because Venus is so absent-minded throughout the narrative that one can't quite sympathize with her efforts. Smith is literally begging for an Oscar in every scene and I wouldn't be surprised if he gets one. It's a similarly digestible and pre-chewed morsel as Green Book was some time ago. Thanks, but I'm sticking with Borg vs. McEnroe. And if you are looking for emotion and psychology, get Untold: Breaking Point. That film speaks about the essence of tennis about a thousand times better and more dramatically than this mess. P.S. There's hardly a film where Bernthal appears and doesn't add a star on top. Give him a big role already. (27/11/2021)

An excellent sports film, appropriately motivational, though, of course, it’s not only about tennis, it has other important messages. Will Smith is fantastic in the lead role, and he portrays such a contradictory character as Richard WIlliams definitely is, with everything he has. Sometimes he oozes infectious enthusiasm, sometimes you want to punch him in the face a little (or more), sometimes he moves you. Still, the film doesn't stand on him and his "plan" alone, as Aunjanue Ellis as his wife and their daughters are just perfect, with Jon Bernthal and Tony Goldwyn also rightfully stealing a lot of the audience's sympathy. P.S.: I would love to see a movie about the movie, with the real Richard Williams on set advising Will Smith on how to play it :) (06/02/2022)

A smart biopic for the whole family; thematically appealing, well scripted, accessible and well acted. It's considerably more a feel-good-vibe movie than an ambitious and raw drama, but it's so skillfully made, with so many worthwhile and entertaining scenes, that most viewers will gobble it up like a raspberry. Will Smith gives one of the best performances of his rich career. (08/01/2022)