Pour une poignée de dollars

Leone’s first foray into western territory meant the arrival of a legend. This Kurosawa remake turned out particularly well and although Sergio was still fine-tuning his directing style to perfection, this is an amazing work. Of course, it can’t compete with Leone’s later masterpieces, which changed the face of cinema forever, but compared to the vast majority of other westerns (and other movies regardless of genre) its quality takes it to completely other spheres. ♫ OST score: 4/5 (03/06/2007)

This cult Western was practically created at the same time as one of my favorite films, Lemonade Joe, which programmatically opposes exactly what Leone did here. That means emphasizing genre clichés, the naivety of the plot, and an unrealistic view of historical events and actions. In the case of Leone's film, nostalgia doesn't work for me at all, which influences, in some cases, more than just my assessment of films, as I didn't see this film during my adolescence. Of course, A Fistful of Dollars is the beginning of the subgenre of spaghetti Westerns, it is a recognized classic, and naturally, I easily find within it practically everything that led to Leone's success. Excellent camera work, scenes designed to maximize the most fundamental human emotions, a sharp contrast between positive and negative characters, cuts to sweaty, bearded faces, and wild gleam in the eyes, a great sense of film detail, and superb casting, which, among other things, helped Clint Eastwood rise to stardom. However, I have a very lukewarm relationship with westerns, as I've mentioned in my reviews several times, so I can't overlook many of the film's unfinished aspects. Leone was still finding himself in this filmmaking genre and honing his directing style. While I forgive genre clichés much more readily in other entertaining genres that I like more, I am unforgiving here. For example, key scenes such as the attack on the military convoy or the destruction of Baxter's hideout are poorly shot and practically cry out for parody. Notice the dozens of male characters, who, after being shot in the chest, tense up, grab their heart, and slowly stagger to the ground with a typical motion. Overall, the script is naive, and a person simply has to turn off their brain. In his later films, Leone added much greater depth of thought, and new motifs, and even Morricone delivered much more emotional performances. When it comes to westerns, I prefer a more realistic style, for example, as demonstrated by the Coen brothers in their new film True Grit. This film lacks much of what I appreciate in cinema, such as realism, rawness, and the internal logic of the story. On the other hand, there are plenty of aspects that repel me from this genre. Overall impression: 40%. (11/09/2011)

This is where it all began. For westerns, for Eastwood and also maybe for Leone. The day when a gunslinger arrived in a small town. The story is simple, but nice, the same as the characters in it. And Clint straining snappy lines through his perpetual cheroot is just delicious. When a man's got money in his pocket he begins to appreciate peace. (04/09/2009)

What an amazing start! When Monco puts a plate under his poncho and learns to shoot again with his crippled hands, I get chills down my spine - and it's the fault of all three gentlemen - Eastwood, Leone and Morricone. Thanks, guys. The final duel, which at one point is amazingly filmed as a shoe fight, must have been such an "event" in its time that all directors of westerns had their eyes popping out of their sockets. Good for them. At least they had a chance to prepare for what was coming in a few years. (18/09/2007)

A beautiful example of how a rigid genre can be pushed somewhere simply by being ignorant of its rules. Many of Leone's trademarks came about practically only by the fact that nobody on set (except Eastwood, who again didn't speak Italian, so he couldn't tell them much) realized that this is simply not how you make a western. A Fistful of Dollars isn't the first Spaghetti Western (there were 20-30 of them at the time), but it's the first one that didn't copy Western techniques. It messed with everyone's head at the time, and the early reviews were pretty fierce, for example, but I totally understand the unique experience it gave rise to in its day and why it was such a hit with audiences. The palpable heat, the sweat, the ugliness, the dust, the thirst, and the sleeping with one eye open. The familiar stuffiness of a forgotten frontier in a time when one could get lost over the horizon. An adventure that does not surrender its naturalistic aspects. Except for the blood, which was probably done by the catering girls. (08/07/2021)

I was shocked at how well a nearly sixty-year-old film worked for me. I don't have a problem with Westerns as such; my problem is that their plot tends to be too simple and, therefore, easily predictable. And spaghetti westerns are no exception in this regard. If I wanted to defend my original four-star rating to myself, I had to look for reasons elsewhere. And I found them. 1) Clint Eastwood was great in the role of a gunslinger (the best as far as I'm concerned), 2) Ennio Morricone was an undisputed musical genius, 3) I enjoyed most of the Italian portrayals of the Wild West more than the authentic American originals (except for a few exceptions). And even though the film has been around for a while now, I can't say that the action scenes were half bad. Sure, you can tell it's an old film, but despite certain reservations, I will rewatch it at some point, which cannot be said about many current movies. So, I really enjoyed the story of a man in the middle who didn't mind whose fire he cooked his beans over. Just the Gatling gun was kind of weird. / Lessons learned: It might come as a shock to the younger generation, but no one in the film uses a mobile phone. (18/06/2023)

Yes, the film "Django Unchained" can be blamed for it. I finally decided to collect all the classic westerns and find out where their magic lies. I used to watch them before, my dad likes them quite a lot, but then I moved away from them, somehow they didn't attract me. I don't really know why, because the idea of the Wild West has always fascinated me and I would like to write stories from this environment myself, although obviously differently than the Italian creators did. Nevertheless, I think these pasta guys gave the world a genre that will forever remain among the best that cinema has ever offered us. "A Fistful of Dollars" is the first film in the dollar trilogy, which is the work of Sergio Leone, who always cast the toughest guys - Clint Eastwood - in the lead role. Although he was just starting his career, at least in the Hollywood sense of the word, even though he was already known as a star of the western series "Rawhide" on TV. It was only here that he showed who he had to play several times. A tough man, almost nameless (almost because even though they profile him as nameless, he is called Joe here), who shoots from his guns damn fast, doesn't say much, and certainly isn't afraid to take someone out. But he also has to count on taking a decent blow every now and then. He ends up covered in blood, so he can rise from the mud and show that there is still a lot in him. A great film, crowned with the brilliant music of Ennio Morricone, who is definitely a musical genius. In my opinion, despite entering the waters of westerns after a very long time, this genre still has something to offer, and that's why I'm holding back a bit, but I think the other films will show me why the creators of these films became such legends. However, as for the final scene, it is absolutely brilliant. More: http://www.filmovy-denik.cz/2013/01/little-ashes-nezapomen-na-me-butter.html (05/03/2013)