Le Coeur a ses raisons

  • Israël Lemale et ha'halal (plus)
Extrait du film 2
Israël, 2012, 90 min

VOD (1)

Résumés(1)

L'histoire d'une famille hassidique orthodoxe vivant à Tel Aviv. Shira, 18 ans, est la plus jeune fille. Elle est sur le point de se marier avec un jeune homme du même âge et du même milieu. C'est un rêve qui devient réalité pour Shira... (ARP Sélection)

Critiques (1)

gudaulin 

Toutes les critiques de l’utilisateur·trice

anglais The film is a credible probe into the life of the Orthodox Jewish community in Israel, which is unsurprising given that the author is a part of it and intimately knows and identifies with the fundamentalist mindset. However, I don't blame her for the insufficient distance from the subject matter. The problem lies in the way it is presented. I categorize the film as noble festival tedium, which has a chance to captivate a limited group of club cinema enthusiasts. Regular viewers will likely find the film tiresome and I wouldn't be surprised if they subjectively perceived its duration as twice as long as in reality. Yes, the actress portraying Shira looks delicate and undeniably charming, and the Jewish community environment is exotic and interesting. Fortunately, there are titles that can reveal the world of the Orthodox more attractively. We don't have to look far, the director's film Wedding Plan is fresher, more likable, and has a realistic chance of appealing to a broader audience. Overall impression: 40%. ()